AITAH – “Or Am I The Asshole” is a reddit forum where people post events in their life and ask strangers on the internet if their reaction to said event was bad making them an ass hole. If I was aware of this forum on reddit many years ago I might write a post something like this: my husband just bought me a brand new phone, after we both agreed I didn’t need a new phone he purchased one anyway, and now I’m angry.

The rest of the post would follow with more details of the event (a true life event that happened to me probably 7 years ago now).
I (33 F) have been married to husband (32 M) for nearly 10yr. We dated almost 4yrs. Recently he wanted to upgrade his cellphone. No big deal I was happy for him. We discussed upgrading my phone too, but we just dropped over $300 on replacing my phone screen and I didn’t think it was financially responsible to buy a brand new one. I’m not big on using my phone. I don’t have games or extra apps. I use my phone mostly for communication, photos, and only use like 4 social media apps. Since we just dropped significant money on getting it fixed I didn’t want or feel the need to get a new phone. I’ve been happy with this one for the 2 years I’ve owned it. My husband agreed. So I was shocked when he returned with his new phone and an exact duplicate for me.
I didn’t get to choose the color, style, or even the model. Nothing. My opinion was completely disregarded and when I tried to explain my shock that I wasn’t prepared, needed, or even wanted a new phone, let alone the one he bought without my input, I was called ungrateful.
Mind you this wasn’t a good surprise. There was no holiday or gift-giving reason for him to splurge on such a purchase and I actually felt a little betrayed. We had already agreed I wasn’t getting a new phone, but he got it anyway.
I’ve already begun feeling like something is off about our relationship, but maybe I’m reading into it too much. It just feels like I should have had a say. We’ve been buying phones together for years and he’s always been supportive of my choices because we use our phones differently and my needs for a cellphone are different from his. We often end up with different models and different colors. But I wasn’t given any options. This led to a big argument (yelling and more). I was told he cannot return it or trade it for a different one. That I am being ungrateful and he was trying to do something nice. I’m just really confused and think something might be wrong with our relationship.
…End of post until a future Update…
If this was a reddit post I’d return with an update months later saying he bought a random toaster oven without consulting me. I’m the only one who cooks and I already was looking into ones I liked. This is becoming some weird pattern.
I should also mention that he’s very aggressive when he argues. He always yells and tells me I’m the one overreacting or degrades me during arguments. I’m beginning to think this relationship is unhealthy and we need therapy. I’ve said I want therapy for myself but he won’t let me.
… I would probably stop here again and then review any reddit responses, as when this happened I was really confused and genuinely felt like maybe I was a jerk for not being happy with his surprise. If I had posted back then maybe I would have seen the red flags sooners and started doing more preparation, but I was allowing my husband (now ex of course) to control me. There were other financial areas that he was completely controlling over, and now of course years later I know it was financial abuse as well as manipulation. At the time I was just confused and feeling like I wasn’t doing enough in the relationship.
Also take a look at my exact words – “He won’t let me” go to therapy for myself. I felt I wasn’t allowed to do a lot of things, which if you pay attention to my language is very telling. I also felt very limited in spending and had to get permission to buy things while he could buy whatever whenever and there was always a million reasons that didn’t make sense, but the arguing was too exhausting so I would give in just to end the yelling. I now know this is an emotional manipulation tactic narcissists like to use on their victims. He had all the energy to fight until I just gave up, and I gave up a lot of myself to this relationship.
Ultimately, my nearly 20 year relationship ended in divorce. The fights got worse, I felt threatened, and thankfully I did get into therapy for myself which gave me enough courage to end this very toxic relationship. These are just fragments of the big picture that was my horrible marriage. It got worse until it ended and I finally got better. I’m a better person. I’m not afraid and I leaned a lot about narcissists from my now ex.
I’m tempted to post my story to reddit, so others can see the behaviors that seem insignificant at the time, but over time grow into a huge issue. Looking back I can see so many tiny ways I was controlled, both with money, and my emotions. I know I’m not the asshole and that the overall feelings I had of betrayal were a huge warning sign my heart was giving me to end things sooner. It took several years and some really big events for me to finally say enough and end things.
I realize now that all the yelling, fighting, arguing for the sake of arguing, were unhealthy. When I started to detach emotionally from the relationship and stop responding to his emotional outbursts, I realized that I could say exactly what he wanted me to like a puppet and he would still roar. I could remain perfectly calm and silent, and he would still roar. My actions did not change him. He needed to fight for himself, not because of anything I did or didn’t do. Once I realized that everything was his problem, I knew there was literally nothing I could do to fix things. And eventually I ended it and again, I am better and more at peace now than I have ever been in my life. Being single and finally learning who I am, has been such a fulfilling journey that I have no desire to bother with another relationship. If it happens, okay, but if I’m single forever, I’m really okay with that. Being alone is so much more peaceful than dealing with even one minute of the nonsense I put up with in my marriage. I refuse to go back.
If you feel any signs of betrayal or question your relationship, it might be your heart telling you something is wrong. Healthy relationships don’t wonder if they are healthy, they are too busy being happy together to worry about all this petty nonsense.





